View: |
Part 1: Document Description
|
Citation |
|
---|---|
Title: |
Replication Data for Voted In, Standing Out: Public Response to Immigrants' Political Accession |
Identification Number: |
doi:10.7910/DVN/IJ2DW4 |
Distributor: |
Harvard Dataverse |
Date of Distribution: |
2024-05-09 |
Version: |
1 |
Bibliographic Citation: |
Grossman, Guy; Zonszein, Stephanie, 2024, "Replication Data for Voted In, Standing Out: Public Response to Immigrants' Political Accession", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/IJ2DW4, Harvard Dataverse, V1 |
Citation |
|
Title: |
Replication Data for Voted In, Standing Out: Public Response to Immigrants' Political Accession |
Identification Number: |
doi:10.7910/DVN/IJ2DW4 |
Authoring Entity: |
Grossman, Guy (University of Pennsylvania) |
Zonszein, Stephanie (University of California Berkeley) |
|
Producer: |
Zonszein, Stephanie |
Distributor: |
Harvard Dataverse |
Access Authority: |
Zonszein, Stephanie |
Depositor: |
Zonszein, Stephanie |
Date of Deposit: |
2023-11-13 |
Holdings Information: |
https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/IJ2DW4 |
Study Scope |
|
Keywords: |
Social Sciences, Intergroup conflict; UK Parliamentary elections; Ethnic minority electoral victories |
Abstract: |
How do dominant-group natives react to immigrants' political integration? We argue that ethnic minority immigrants winning political office makes natives feel threatened, triggering animosity. We test this dynamic across the 2010--2019 UK general elections, using hate crime police records, public opinion data, and text data from over 500,000 regional and local newspaper articles. While past work has not established a causal relationship between minorities' political power gains and dominant group animosity, we identify natives' hostile reactions with a regression discontinuity design that leverages close election results between immigrant-origin ethnic minority and dominant-group candidates. We find that minority victories increase hate crimes by 67%, exclusionary attitudes by 66%, and negative media coverage of immigrant groups by 110%. Consistent with power threat and social identity theories, these findings demonstrate a strong and widespread negative reaction---encompassing a violence-prone fringe and the mass public---against ethnic minority immigrants' integration into majority settings. |
Notes: |
This dataset underwent an independent verification process, complying with the AJPS Verification Policy updated June 2023, which replicated the tables and figures in the primary article. For the supplementary materials, verification was performed solely for the successful execution of the code. The verification process was carried out by the Cornell Center for Social Sciences at Cornell University. <br></br> The associated article has been awarded the Open Materials Badge. Learn more about the Open Practice Badges from the <a href="https://www.cos.io/">Center for Open Science</a>. <br></br> <img src="https://socialsciences.cornell.edu/sites/default/files/2024-04/materials_large_color.png" alt="Open Materials Badge " width="60" height="60"> <br></br> Open Materials Badge |
Methodology and Processing |
|
Sources Statement |
|
Data Sources: |
Keane, Sean. 2021. “Recorded crime data by Community Safety Partnership area in England and Wales”. Crime and Policing Analysis Unit, Home Office. FOI 62412 February 2021. |
<br></br> Office for National Statistics. 2011. “2011 Census”. Nomis, Official Census and Labour Market Statistics. URL: https://www.nomisweb.co.uk/sources/census_2011. |
|
<br></br> Whiteley, P.F. and D. Sanders. 2014. “British Election Study, 2010: Face-to-Face Survey.”. URL: https://www.britishelectionstudy.com/data-objects/cross-sectional-data. |
|
<br></br> Fieldhouse, E., J. Green, G. Evans, H. Schmitt, C. van der Eijk, J. Mellon and C. Prosser. 2019. “British Election Study, 2015: Face-to-Face Post-Election Survey.”. URL: https://www.britishelectionstudy.com/data-objects/cross-sectional-data/ |
|
<br></br> Fieldhouse, E., J. Green, G. Evans, H. Schmitt, C. van der Eijk, J. Mellon and C. Prosser. 2019b. “British Election Study, 2017: Face-to-Face Post-Election Survey.”. URL: https://www.britishelectionstudy.com/data-objects/cross-sectional-data/ |
|
<br></br> Fieldhouse, E., J. Green, G. Evans, C. Prosser, R. de Geus, J. Bailey, H. Schmitt, C. van der Eijk and J. Mellon. 2022. “British Election Study, 2019: Post-Election Random Probability Survey.”. URL: https://www.britishelectionstudy.com/data-objects/cross-sectional-data/ |
|
<br></br> Common Crawl. 2008. URL: https://commoncrawl.org/ |
|
<br></br> The Electoral Commission. 2010. 2010 UK Parliament Spending Data. URL: https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/sites/default/files/excel_doc/2010-UK-Parliament-spending-data-Excel.xls |
|
<br></br> The Electoral Commission. 2015. Results and turnout at the 2015 UK general election. URL: https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/research-reports-and-data/our-reports-and-data-past-elections-and-referendums/results-and-turnout-2015-uk-general-election. |
|
<br></br> The Electoral Commission. 2017. Results and turnout at the 2017 UK general election. URL: https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/research-reports-and-data/our-reports-and-data-past-elections-and-referendums/results-and-turnout-2017-uk-general-election. |
|
<br></br> UK Parliament House of Commons Library. 2020. General Election 2019: full results and analysis. URL: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8749/. |
|
<br></br> Norris, Pippa. 2020. British General Election Constituency Results, 2010-2019. URL: https://www.pippanorris.com/data/. |
|
<br></br> van Heerde-Hudson, Jennifer and Rosie Campbell. 2015. “Parliamentary Candidates UK Dataset.”. Leverhulme Trust (RPG-2013-175). URL: http://www.parliamentarycandidates.org/. |
|
<br></br> Office for National Statistics. 2001. “2001 Census”. Nomis, Official Census and Labour Market Statistics. URL:https://www.nomisweb.co.uk/sources/census_2001. |
|
<br></br> Office for National Statistics. 2011. “2011 Census”. Nomis, Official Census and Labour Market Statistics. URL: https://www.nomisweb.co.uk/sources/census_2011. |
|
Data Access |
|
Disclaimer: |
The <i>American Journal of Political Science</i> and the Cornell Center for Social Sciences are not responsible for the accuracy or quality of data uploaded within the <i>AJPS</i> Dataverse, for the use of those data, or for interpretations or conclusions based on their use. |
Other Study Description Materials |
|
Label: |
README |
Notes: |
text/plain; charset=US-ASCII |
Label: |
0_install_packages.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figure1_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figure2.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figure3_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figure4_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureB1_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureD1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureD2_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureE1_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG10_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG11_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG12_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG1_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG2_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG3_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG4_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG5_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG6.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG8.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureG9_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureH1_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureH2_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI1_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI2_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI3_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI4_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI5.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureI6.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureJ1_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureJ2_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureJ3_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureJ4_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureJ5_a_b.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
figureK1_a_b_c.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
table1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
table2.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
table3.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableA1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableD1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableF1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableG1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableG2_figureG7.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableG3.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableI1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableI2.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableJ1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
tableK1.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
gsynth_1.0.9.tar.gz |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
DESCRIPTION |
Notes: |
text/plain; charset=US-ASCII |
Label: |
MD5 |
Notes: |
text/plain; charset=US-ASCII |
Label: |
NAMESPACE |
Notes: |
text/plain; charset=US-ASCII |
Label: |
README.md |
Notes: |
text/markdown |
Label: |
gsynth.RData |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
gsynth-internal.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
gsynth-package.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
gsynth.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
interFE.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
plot.gsynth.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
print.gsynth.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
print.interFE.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
simdata.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
turnout.Rd |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
gsynth.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
interFE.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
RcppExports.R |
Notes: |
type/x-r-syntax |
Label: |
gsynth.so |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
interFE.cpp |
Notes: |
text/x-c |
Label: |
interFE.o |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
Makevars |
Notes: |
text/plain; charset=US-ASCII |
Label: |
Makevars.win |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
RcppExports.cpp |
Notes: |
text/x-c |
Label: |
RcppExports.o |
Notes: |
application/octet-stream |
Label: |
Codebook_Citations_for_Original_Data_Sources.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
attitudes.rds |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
attitudes_before_election.rds |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'attitudes.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'attitudes_before_election.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
covars_attitudes.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
campaign_issues.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'campaign_issues.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
candidates_assigned_religion.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'candidates_assigned_religion.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'minority_candidates_2010_2019.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
minority_candidates_2010_2019.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'demographic.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
demographic.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'hate_crime.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'hate_crime_before_election.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'hate_crime_did_analysis.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'hate_crime_violent.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'hate_crime_white_candidates.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'lad_to_constituency_validation.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
covars_crime.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
hate_crime.RDS |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
hate_crime_before_election.RDS |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
hate_crime_did_analysis.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
hate_crime_violent.RDS |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
hate_crime_white_candidates.RDS |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
lad_to_constituency_validation.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'demographic_change.rds'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
demographic_change.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
articles_word_frequency.rds |
Notes: |
application/x-rlang-transport |
Label: |
article_locations.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
codebook_'articles_word_frequency.rds'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'article_locations.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_3_classification_categories.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_before_elections.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_no_crime.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_paper_alignment.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_paper_circulation.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_paper_ideology.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'media_placebo.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'mentions_candidate_sentiment.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
codebook_'mentions_candidate_subregion.RDS'.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
covars_media.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_3_classification_categories.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_before_election.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_no_crime.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_paper_alignment.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_paper_circulation.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_paper_ideology.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_placebo.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
mentions_candidate_sentiment.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
mentions_candidate_subregion.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
Westminster_Parliamentary_Constituencies__December_2017__UK_BSC_V2.xml |
Notes: |
text/xml |
Label: |
Westminster_Parliamentary_Constituencies__December_2017__UK_BSC_V2.zip |
Notes: |
application/zipped-shapefile |
Label: |
crime_estimates.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
crime_placebo_estimates.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
media_estimates.RDS |
Notes: |
application/gzip |
Label: |
figure1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure2.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure3a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure3b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure4a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figure4b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureB1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureB1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureD1.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureD2a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureD2b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureE1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureE1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureE1c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG10a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG10b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG11a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG11b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG12a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG12b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG1c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG2a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG2b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG2c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG3a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG3b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG3c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG4a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG4b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG5a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG5b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG6.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG7.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG8.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG9a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG9b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureG9c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureH1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureH1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureH1c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureH2a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureH2b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI2a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI2b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI2c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI3a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI3b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI3c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI4a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI4b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI5.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureI6.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ1c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ2a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ2b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ2c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ3a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ3b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ3c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ4a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ4b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ4c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ5a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureJ5b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureK1a.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureK1b.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
figureK1c.pdf |
Notes: |
application/pdf |
Label: |
table1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
table2.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
table3.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableA1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableD1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableF1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableG1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableG2.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableG3.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableI1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableI2.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableJ1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |
Label: |
tableK1.tex |
Notes: |
application/x-tex |